1. Do you agree with the Supreme Court of Canada’s resolution of this case? Please explain. 2. What if the mental injury sustained by Mustapha would occur in a person of ordinary fortitude, would Culligan be responsible for the full extent of Mustapha’s loss? Please explain. 3. What if Mustapha had told Culligan that he would suffer a severe and prolonged mental injury if he saw flies in the water, would the court’s decision have changed, in contract and/or in negligence? Please explain.
